Happy New Year from SocEntLaw! And, for my fellow academics, welcome back to school!
As we begin 2014, I decided to post on the current state of the law concerning hybrid business entities: benefit corporations, flexible purpose corporations, social purpose corporations, benefit LLCs, and low-profit limited liability companies (“L3Cs”). For more detailed information on these new entities (including citations to the relevant statutes), see my updated social enterprise entity comparison chart posted on SSRN here.
L3Cs: First, with respect to L3Cs, North Carolina conspicuously repealed its L3C statute effective January 1, 2014. Therefore, only eight states now authorize L3Cs: Illinois, Louisiana, Maine, Michigan, Rhode Island, Utah, Vermont, and Wyoming.
Benefit LLCs: The number of benefit LLC states remains at two. Only Maryland and Oregon authorize benefit LLCs.
Flexible/Social Purpose Corporations: Only one state, California, authorizes flexible purpose corporations, while only two states, Texas and Washington, authorize social purpose corporations.
Benefit Corporations: The current number of benefit corporation states is trickier to determine. Altogether, nineteen states and the District of Columbia have enacted some form of benefit corporation legislation; however, a couple of those states have delayed the effective date for their benefit corporation statutes. Jurisdictions with currently effective benefit corporation legislation include the District of Columbia and seventeen states: Arkansas, California, Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Louisiana, Maryland, Massachusetts, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, Vermont, and Virginia. Two states have passed benefit corporation statutes that (absent further action) will become effective at a future date. Specifically, Colorado’s benefit corporation statute becomes effective April 1, 2014—Really? April Fools’ Day?—while Arizona’s benefit corporation statute becomes effective January 1, 2015.
Predictions: What will 2014 bring with respect to hybrid business entity statutes? Only time will tell, but I’m willing to make a few reckless predictions. I believe that the count of states with benefit corporation legislation roughly will double in 2014. Therefore, I predict that by January 1, 2015, thirty-five or more states will authorize benefit corporations. I predict that the number of states authorizing flexible purpose and social purpose corporations will increase slightly in 2014, but I would be surprised if more than five or six states have flexible purpose or social purpose corporation statutes by January 1, 2015. Finally, I predict that no additional states will enact either L3C legislation or benefit LLC legislation in 2014. In fact, I would not be surprised if more states follow North Carolina in 2014 and repeal their L3C statutes.
Regardless of my predictions, there is one thing we absolutely can count on in 2014 with respect to hybrid business entities: CHANGE!